The records needed for an expert nursing and clinical operations review vary depending on the allegations, facility type, jurisdiction, and scope of the requested opinion. When evaluating care provided in a substance use disorder treatment, withdrawal management, detoxification, residential treatment, or behavioral health setting, relevant materials may include:
Patient Clinical Record
-
Complete medical and clinical record for the admission at issue
-
Admission and intake documentation
-
Nursing assessments and reassessments
-
Medical history and physical examination
-
Provider evaluations and progress notes
-
Nursing and behavioral health progress notes
-
Vital-sign and observation records
-
Withdrawal assessments, including CIWA-Ar, COWS, or other applicable tools
-
Medication Administration Records (MARs)
-
Physician or advanced practice provider orders
-
Laboratory and toxicology results
-
Urine drug-screen and breath-alcohol results
-
Treatment and individualized care plans
-
Behavioral health and counseling documentation
-
Communication between nursing staff, providers, and other members of the treatment team
-
Transfer, discharge, AMA, or emergency-department documentation
-
EMS, emergency-department, and subsequent hospital records when applicable
-
Death certificate, coroner/medical examiner report, and toxicology findings when applicable
Facility Policies and Procedures
Policies and procedures in effect at the time of the incident, particularly those addressing:
-
Admission, screening, and exclusion criteria
-
Withdrawal management and monitoring
-
Nursing assessment and reassessment
-
Vital signs and changes in condition
-
Provider notification and escalation of care
-
Emergency response and EMS activation
-
Overdose recognition and response
-
Naloxone availability and administration
-
Medication management
-
Contraband and prohibited substances
-
Searches of persons, belongings, and personal property
-
Observation, rounds, and client monitoring
-
Drug and alcohol testing
-
Documentation requirements
-
Incident reporting
-
Staffing and supervision
-
Staff orientation, education, and competency requirements
Staffing and Personnel Records
For the relevant dates and shifts:
-
Staffing schedules and assignment sheets
-
Staff-to-client census or staffing records
-
Timecards or other records confirming personnel actually on duty
-
Job descriptions
-
Licensure and certification information
-
Personnel qualification records
-
Orientation records
-
Required annual or recurring training records
-
Competency validations
-
Overdose and emergency-response training
-
Naloxone training
-
CPR/BLS certification, when applicable
-
Withdrawal-management education and competency records
-
Agency or temporary-staff qualification and orientation records, when applicable
Facility and Regulatory Records
-
Facility license and licensing classification in effect on the date of the incident
-
Approved level or scope of services
-
Applicable state licensing regulations
-
Applicable federal regulations
-
Accreditation standards, when applicable
-
Licensing surveys, inspection reports, plans of correction, citations, or deficiencies relevant to the issues under review
-
Organizational chart
-
Medical director and clinical oversight structure
-
Nursing leadership and supervisory structure
-
Contracts or agreements governing medical/provider coverage when relevant
Incident and Quality Records
-
Incident or unusual-occurrence reports
-
Internal investigation documents, when available and discoverable
-
Statements from involved staff or witnesses
-
Emergency-response documentation
-
Post-incident reviews
-
Corrective action plans
-
Relevant quality-assurance or performance-improvement documentation, when available and discoverable
-
Prior similar incident information when relevant and legally available
Case and Litigation Materials
-
Complaint or petition
-
Answer and other relevant pleadings
-
Demand letter or statement of allegations
-
Deposition transcripts
-
Written discovery responses
-
Witness statements
-
Relevant expert reports
-
Relevant exhibits, photographs, video, or surveillance footage
-
Timeline or chronology prepared by counsel, if available
Additional Records Based on the Issues Presented
Additional documentation may be requested after the initial review. This may include records necessary to evaluate staffing adequacy, staff training and competency, compliance with facility policies and regulatory requirements, recognition and response to changes in condition, communication and escalation of care, and whether the care and operational practices provided were consistent with applicable nursing and clinical standards.